I often meet with a long-running, well-known nonprofit to discuss the workflow for a rejuvenated social media presence that helps them keep up with the competition. I’ll ask questions like, “How often do you post to Instagram Stories?” or “How many videos do you produce per week?” They respond that it’s a miracle if they get an uninterrupted lunch break every day. 

This is the reality behind nonprofit social media: when you cut through the relentless pace and demands, it’s astounding that so many manage to stay active. But when you finally do carve out the time to post, how do you measure success? I frequently see organizations celebrating a massive follower count or number of likes (we call these vanity metrics), but raw numbers don’t necessarily mean social media is working well. Only 5-20% of your followers will see your organic posts, and they’re unlikely to immediately see your content and take an action like donating or volunteering without months or years of priming. 

Smart nonprofits manage social media channels that just WORK. That means turning the building blocks of your content into awareness, donor support and credibility. Here is how we did that with one of our clients.

From Metrics to Mission

I’ve found that the most profound insights often come from looking at what happens when a nonprofit radically shifts its content strategy.

I once had a client who had no idea whether their social media was actually working, and it seemed like the more time they put into it, the more it became a bottomless bucket of resources. They wanted to post every day and fill their feed with generic announcements and reminders, without a story or human face in sight. We had our work cut out for us, and the first step was cutting these posts down to a few consistent times per week. Over-posting is a surefire way to wear out your audience – digital fatigue is very real. But that was just the beginning. 

Next, we helped them pivot to a strategy of posting intentionally chosen, human stories centered on photos and videos, using each real-world example to lead the audience to a direct call to action that drove them to an owned channel. This meant visiting their headquarters and interviewing staff, volunteers and clients on-camera. Here’s an example of a client who does human stories exceptionally well, and sees it pay off in multiple ways. In our work with the Lymphoma Research Foundation, we’ve executed influencer campaigns that tie fundraising to the diverse cancer journeys of lymphoma survivors from across the country. When we worked with the Twitch streamer Blizzb3ear, he generated thousands of engagements and web visits for the Foundation and raised over $2,500 for cancer research. Telling the human story behind your mission is the key to turning social media results into real-world momentum. 

Second, we integrated their earned media with their owned social media channels. It’s important not to work in a silo. When nonprofits elevate the same issues in the press that they discuss on social media, they reinforce a clear, consistent narrative, which is exactly what we did. When they appeared in The New York Times or other outlets, those same stories showed up on their audience’s feeds as highly successful posts that generated deep engagement, like saves and shares. These are also the kinds of engagement the algorithm looks for before recommending your posts to new audiences.

Third, we made sure each post had a clear, trackable call to action. We measured this campaign’s success with unique links and web traffic analytics. Whether you’re analyzing your latest influencer campaign or measuring how many users joined a fundraiser, it’s imperative to know that users are being funneled into your owned channels. That’s why social media is referred to as a “top of the funnel” channel. In this situation, we applied a dedicated content strategy to each channel (a professional audience on LinkedIn wants thought leadership, not memes), and reported back on donations, form applications and volunteer sign-ups from dedicated pieces of content, refining them until we earned the impact we wanted.

Impact by the Numbers

Our social strategy revamp was successful in three ways. First, by posting on a consistent three-post-per-week cadence, we saw posts viewed 50% more. Less is more, after all! Second, we tracked donations and user actions in the most important phase – the move from social media channels to the website. The Foundation started seeing more and more volunteers sign up from a new source: Instagram. Third, by opening content with a relatable story or thought-provoking media piece that put their mission and community at the fore, they saw engagement (saves, shares) rise by 46%. As a result of this boost in algorithmic discovery, their audience growth rate increased by a whopping 85%. Now that’s social media that works!

When you stop posting because you think you should, and start posting to build community, the metrics that matter will inevitably rise. Effective communication is imperative to activating the next generation who will carry your mission forward. If you’re not sure if your organization’s social media is working, visit our services page. By redefining what success looks like, trading vanity likes for high-intent website actions, strategic engagement and media amplification, you ensure your digital strategy is an engine for growth rather than a drain on your already dwindling capacity. Stop chasing the algorithm, cut through the noise and start tracking the metrics that matter to your mission.